Page 4 of 7

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 1:31 am
by StitchMallone
All good and got ya and makes sense for now! Ps. I wasn't trying to be a D to you and like your post.

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 2:05 am
by Xcaliber
If he left his right palm print on the cab door frame while he reached back in he may have been left-handed.

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 2:22 am
by StitchMallone
Xcaliber wrote:If he left his right palm print on the cab door frame while he reached back in he may have been left-handed.
Glad I brought up left handed but not for that but makes sense. You are going to brace yourself with your less dominant hand while reaching in with your dominant hand. So he may have brace himself on the cab with his right hand.

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 7:14 am
by masootz
without knowing the position of stine's head as he was shot it's not possible to say with certainty where the killer was sitting. if we had more details on blood spatter then we might make a guess, but we don't. so stine could have been looking forward, looking to his right, leaning forward, etc. as for the "no evidence zodiac was in the back", not to be pedantic but there's no evidence zodiac rode in the car. the kids saw him sitting in the front but technically he could have walked up to the cab after stine let out his last passenger, however we assume that he took the cab ride as it's the least assumptive of the likely options. as a default i assume zodiac sat in the back of the cab because that's how people usually ride in a cab. you might take someone's sister saying someone from le told her something as gospel but i don't. there's enough third party conjecture used as evidence in this case as it is.

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 8:03 am
by replaceablehead
Some hearsay testimony is better than other. It's not binary. In this instance the claim is very straightforward and unembellished. The story has changed hands a few times, but it's not really a complex story, it's one "fact", and the type of "fact" that should be simple enough to remember passing from the top cop, to the sister, to Tom. It's hard to believe any of the three could have gone that far wrong over such a simple detail.

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 8:23 am
by masootz
replaceablehead wrote:Some hearsay testimony is better than other. It's not binary. In this instance the claim is very straightforward and unembellished. The story has changed hands a few times, but it's not really a complex story, it's one "fact", and the type of "fact" that should be simple enough to remember passing from the top cop, to the sister, to Tom. It's hard to believe any of the three could have gone that far wrong over such a simple detail.


we'll agree to disagree on the reliability of that particular chain of custody.

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 9:21 am
by Chaucer
Yes, I think it's fair to say that there are many variables that could affect the trajectory of the shot including where Zodiac was sitting, Stine's head movement, etc. There's no way to know for sure Zodiac's location within the vehicle without other evidence.

Still, I believe that Zodiac sitting in the rear of the cab behind the passenger seat makes the most sense. It provides the most logical explanation for the angle of the shot. Assuming Stine was relatively stationary and facing forward, if Zodiac was sitting directly behind or just adjacent and behind Stine, he would have to bend his arm at an awkward angle to put the gun to Stine's head. If he was sitting directly next to Stine, he would have to reach across his body and lean over awkwardly to place the gun to his head.

If he is sitting in the rear of the cab behind the passenger seat, all he has to do is lean slightly forward, reach across the seat, put the gun Stine's head and fire. This would account for the forward/downward trajectory of the bullet.

Also, if you were a mass murderer planning on shooting a cab driver, would you want to sit next to him so that he could easily see your movements and actions and potentially your knife and gun? Or would you rather sit in the rear, out of view? Also, would you rather sit next to the man you are shooting at close range where you could potentially be covered in blood and brains? Or would you rather sit in the rear furthest from the driver where the blood and brains would be separated from you by a seat?

Both in terms of trajectory and logically, a position behind the passenger seat of the cab makes the most sense. Just an educated guess.

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 9:58 am
by Quicksilver
I was going through the crime scene photos and the right rear window is definitely rolled down and the right front wing is open...hard for me to tell if the right front window is down in the photos because of the light. However, there is a photo taken from the opposite side of the vehicle that shows the interior window roller handles in close to the same position on both doors. Was it possible that Zodiac shot Stine from the outside?

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 10:06 am
by masootz
Quicksilver wrote:I was going through the crime scene photos and the right rear window is definitely rolled down and the right front wing is open...hard for me to tell if the right front window is down in the photos because of the light. However, there is a photo taken from the opposite side of the vehicle that shows the interior window roller handles in close to the same position on both doors. Was it possible that Zodiac shot Stine from the outside?


recalling from memory, but i think the gunshot residue on his head indicated the gun was very near or contacting his head when fired.

Re: Sitting In the Front Seat

PostPosted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 10:41 am
by Cragle
There are a couple of things worthy of note in this. Firstly from the Crime Scene report, the spent shell casing was found in the Front passenger side footwell.

PS Crime Report.jpg