Page 4 of 5

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 12:51 am
by Skyward
CuriousCat wrote:
Because his mom bought them for him. Can't compare it to Zodiac's era, different time, different laws.


She left him checks to purchase but he did buy guns himself, he also went to the shooting range himself.

Now, Z did have some ammo sold mostly from military supply outlets, this is a loose end for our suspect.

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 2:18 am
by solvethemystery
Interesting documentary on YouTube: Schizophrenia - Full documentary on how schizophrenia effects individuals and relationships ==>> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnoUKWXTcBU

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 10:11 am
by Zresearch
solvethemystery wrote:
Zresearch wrote:
solvethemystery wrote:Zodiac gives us another clue to his schizophrenic mental illness in the Cheri Jo Bates confession letter: "I AM NOT SICK. I AM INSANE. BUT THAT WILL NOT STOP THE GAME."


I think it is ridiculous to suggest that zodiac was schizophrenic.



The gait issues of Zodiac suggest otherwise. They are consistent with the gait of a schizophrenic.


So just because he may have been "lumbering" or "shuffling" away from a crime scene means he was schizophrenic?

You can not diagnose schizophrenia just examining a person's style of walking.

The walking may have fit a similar style of walking as a schizophrenic, but so many other pieces do not fit. ...besides, at the stine scene he would have been covered in blood, adrenaline pumping, while trying to conceal a piece of the victims shirt and a gun, it wouldn't be a normal situation.

I also know schizophrenics who walk completely normally.

...and suggesting he was "walking like a schizophrenic" is a bit of a reach, all you have to go on is brief descriptions on paper.

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 10:25 am
by solvethemystery
Zresearch wrote:
You can not diagnose schizophrenia just examining a person's style of walking.

The walking may have fit a similar style of walking as a schizophrenic, but so many other pieces do not fit. ...besides, at the stine scene he would have been covered in blood, adrenaline pumping, while trying to conceal a piece of the victims shirt and a gun, it wouldn't be a normal situation.


Straw man fallacy. Saying something "is consistent with" is different than making a diagnosis.

Zodiac was wearing dark clothes, including a dark navy windbreaker. And it was night time. Any blood splatter droplets soaking into a dark cotton jacket may not be readily visible to Fouke who was driving by in a car and only viewed the subject for a matter of seconds (as he was looking for a black male).

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 10:28 am
by Zresearch
MMSox wrote:
Zresearch wrote:...would make executing these crimes, and not slipping up or not getting caught, very very very difficult for a true schizophrenic. Also, as a result of their illness obtaining and owning a gun would be quite difficult. Also having the freedom and time to commit these crimes does not seem fitting for a schizophrenic.


In 2017, absolutely correct. In the mid-late 60s, not so much. PDs didn’t work together like now, wasn’t dna, guns could be purchased by mail, there wasn’t as many meds, oversight, etc. He was able to take advantage of the times.


I can not argue with you there, it was a different time and as a result a mentally ill person could have taken advantage.

But...

...because of my sister's husband's brother (who is schizophrenic) and through knowing his friends who are affected by the same illness, I have a pretty good idea of how the illness affects people, there are varieties of the disorder, for example: paranoid schizophrenia, hebephrenic schizophrenia, catatonic schizophrenia, and schizoaffective disorder, and while in 2013 all these varieties were considered to be one illness, there definitely are varieties of the disorder, and I honestly can not see zodiac as being a true schizophrenic of any type.

Another issue the schizophrenic in my family has is other people holding this belief that schizophrenics are dangerous or murderous individuals, in all honestly, dealing with a schizophrenic is a lot like dealing with a person who has been given LSD with out their knowledge or consent, and most the time they come off as being more "silly" than "scary", regardless, it is a severely debilitating condition, and I can not see a person affected by schizophrenia being able to do what zodiac did.

Zodiac did not appear delusional, he did not appear confused or out of touch with reality, he appeared as a person who was calculating, organized, and who knew exactly what he was doing.

I do not mean to come off as rude in any way, but I feel the more people that you know who are actually schizophrenic, the harder it would be for you to accept that zodiac suffered from this same condition. They don't seem fitting at all.

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 10:40 am
by MMSox
I have worked with adults with mental disabilities for over 10 years now. They range from mild to very severe. There are some with schizophrenia and even multiple personality disorder. I understand your point and to a certain extent, agree. That said, I’m continually surprised by some of the schemes that can be conjured up by guys I wouldn’t have ever expected it from. I’m less likely to think his behavior was that of a schizophrenic, but his physical motions do add up. I wouldn’t say yes or no to someone just based on having this disease.

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 10:42 am
by Zresearch
solvethemystery wrote:
Zresearch wrote:
You can not diagnose schizophrenia just examining a person's style of walking.

The walking may have fit a similar style of walking as a schizophrenic, but so many other pieces do not fit. ...besides, at the stine scene he would have been covered in blood, adrenaline pumping, while trying to conceal a piece of the victims shirt and a gun, it wouldn't be a normal situation.


Straw man fallacy. Saying something "is consistent with" is different than making a diagnosis.

Zodiac was wearing dark clothes, including a dark navy windbreaker. And it was night time. Any blood splatter droplets soaking into a dark cotton jacket may not be readily visible to Fouke who was driving by in a car and only viewed the subject for a matter of seconds (as he was looking for a black male).


No, I mention that he was covered in blood, adrenalin pumping, while trying to conceal his weapon and the murder victims shirt after just shooting the man because it could have been enough to induce an altered gait. It was not a normal situation, so he may not have been walking normally.

To judge a person's mental health by a description of how they may have been walking which was written on paper, is a reach, and in the stine case the officers are said to have just passed by him not getting a good look. (Though other sources say they actually talked with the man) so the officers who wrote the report only glimpsed the man.)

And while you could say "his walking is consistent with that of a schizophrenic"*, everything else is absolutely inconsistent with a person affected by schizophrenia. Besides, reading a report of how a person was walking, and watching a person walk are two totally different things.

*I know plenty of schizophrenic individuals who walk completely normal, and I also know mentally healthy individuals that have a "gait consistent with that of a scizophrenic"

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 10:55 am
by Skyward
Well done documentary, tragic fragmentation of intelligent minds, the twins, one with and one without, were amazing. Does bring up questions, as Morf said earlier after P.I. notes. With each person reacting uniquely to disease, certainly it is feasible Z had this condition. The question posed half way through to the twin as to what he might do if he did not take medication...elicited an answer 'I might try to kill someone.'

Looking for more handwriting from our suspect, knowing Z had some form of psychosis, knowing the ciphers would be an undertaking of some hardship for a patient with this disorder, but knowing our POI Ross' affinity for cryptography....and seeing the art student still able to achieve results in the documentary, difficult as it was....can the pieces fit together, with mental health in background, at all times, for Ross?....types of medication (the documentary quoted 1950's as first time when a certain anti-psychotic drug of choice began) and the need for solid in and out-patient treatment timeline(s) others here have mentioned, to put him into population circa 1969?

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 10:59 am
by solvethemystery
Zresearch wrote:
I know plenty of schizophrenic individuals who walk completely normal, and I also know mentally healthy individuals that have a "gait consistent with that of a scizophrenic"


Let's deal with data and statistics, instead of the imprecision of "who you know."

Prevalence rates of motor symptoms in schizophrenia patients

Image

Source: https://www.karger.com/Article/Fulltext/339456

Re: Schizophrenic gait "Shuffling lope, bent forward, head d

PostPosted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 11:03 am
by solvethemystery
Skyward wrote:
Looking for more handwriting from our suspect, knowing Z had some form of psychosis...


Here's an interesting 1969 news article in which William F. Baker, a handwriting analyst who held a masters in psychology and abnormal psychology, concluded that Zodiac: "is unquestionably paranoid and schizophrenic."

Image