themysterymachine wrote:
Being that RPD brought in SFPD even tho they didn't believe their guy was Z, I can' t think we are dealing with the brightest bulbs in the universe. That still bothers me no end- WHY would you bring in a reporter, give him documents, and lessen your case against your man? If that is any indication, I can see where RPD may not have always done everything with the utmost of professionalism.
They contacted other PDs and had the Bates prints compared to the Z prints - which was professional of them, if you ask me. There was no match - and from there on they seem to have been convinced either that a) "Bob" was their man or b) generally that Z didn't kill Bates.
Avery was tipped off by someone, he wasn't brought in formally by the RPD - and they didn't give him any documents either, AFAIK.
Perhaps they weren't the brightest bulbs, as you say, but that is a matter of speculation. Plus, we have no idea what the nature of Ross' alibi actually is. And still people seem willing to speculate that it may be no good - based on absolutely nothing.
